Review Collection Checklist for New Businesses

Customer reviews are essential for building trust, boosting visibility, and driving sales for new businesses. Here's why:

• Trust & Credibility: 88% of people trust reviews as much as personal recommendations.
• Purchase Decisions: 90% are influenced by reviews more than sales pitches.
• SEO Impact: Reviews influence 9% of Google’s search rankings, improving local visibility.
• Social Proof: 73% of customers find reviews older than 3 months irrelevant; fresh reviews matter.

Key Steps to Collect Reviews:

1. Set Clear Goals: Use SMART goals, e.g., "Get 25 Google reviews with a 4.5-star average in 60 days."
2. Choose Platforms: Focus on Google, Yelp, Facebook, or industry-specific sites like TripAdvisor or Trustpilot.
3. Automate Collection: Use tools like QR codes, email, or SMS to make leaving reviews easy.
4. Respond Quickly: 53% of customers expect replies to negative reviews within a week.
5. Track Metrics: Monitor review quantity, response rates, and impact on traffic or sales.

Tools to Simplify Review Management:

• kisReviews: Automates review requests and consolidates feedback from multiple platforms. Plans range from free to $50/year.

Avoid Common Issues:

• Low Response Rates: Send follow-ups, keep surveys short, and offer small incentives.
• Negative Reviews: Respond within 24–48 hours, apologize, and resolve issues offline.

By implementing these strategies, you can turn customer feedback into trust, better visibility, and more sales.

Where, When, and How to Ask for Customer Reviews

Setting Clear Goals for Review Collection

Customer reviews are powerful, but to truly harness their potential, you need clear goals to steer your efforts. Well-defined objectives help you focus and channel your energy effectively.

Why Set Review Collection Goals?

Having specific goals - like aiming for 20 Google reviews in your first month or maintaining a 4.5-star average - transforms vague aspirations into actionable plans. A structured approach ensures you consistently gather valuable feedback while also allowing you to measure progress and tweak strategies as needed.

One effective method for setting these objectives is using SMART goals: Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, and Time-bound. For instance, instead of saying, "We need more reviews", a SMART goal might be: "Collect 25 Google reviews with an average rating of 4.0 or higher within the next 60 days." This clarity not only sharpens your focus but also keeps your team aligned with measurable targets.

Connecting Reviews to Business Goals

When your review collection goals align with broader business objectives, every piece of feedback becomes part of a bigger picture. For example, if your priority is improving local visibility, you might focus on gathering Google My Business reviews that emphasize your location. On the other hand, if earning customer trust is your goal, you could encourage detailed reviews that highlight your expertise and dedication to quality.

This alignment between reviews and business outcomes can lead to substantial results. Companies with tightly aligned strategies grow revenue 58% faster and are 72% more profitable than those without such alignment. Take the case of Colorcon, a pharmaceutical company. In February 2024, they introduced a performance system that tied employee goals to company objectives, using quick feedback loops and weekly bonuses. When teams see how customer reviews directly impact metrics like search rankings, conversion rates, or credibility, they approach review collection with more purpose and motivation.

These aligned goals not only improve performance but also set the stage for choosing the right tools and platforms for review collection.

Key Metrics to Track

To make your review collection efforts effective and manageable, focus on a handful of key performance indicators (KPIs). Aim for 5–7 metrics that provide meaningful insights without overwhelming your team.

• Review Quantity Metrics: Track how many reviews you collect each month. This helps you spot growth trends and seasonal patterns in customer feedback.
• Response Rate Metrics: Measure how often customers respond to your review requests. Break it down by communication method - email, text, or in-person - to identify what works best.
• Review Quality Indicators: Don’t just look at star ratings. Monitor the proportion of reviews with detailed feedback, overall sentiment, and your average rating. These insights offer a deeper understanding of customer perceptions.
• Business Impact Metrics: Connect your reviews to tangible outcomes. Analyze how they influence website traffic, lead generation, conversion rates, and revenue. Regularly revisiting these metrics ensures your strategy stays relevant and aligned with your business goals.

As Tomas Keenan, Founder of Step It Up Academy, puts it:

KPIs provide valuable insights that help inform decisions, allowing businesses to make more informed choices about how best to achieve their desired outcomes.

Selecting the Right Platforms and Tools

Once you've set clear goals for gathering reviews, the next step is deciding where to focus your efforts. Since Google searches drive a large portion of local traffic, picking the right platforms is crucial for boosting visibility.

Choosing Platforms That Fit Your Business

Your platform choice should align with your business type and audience. Google reviews should always be a priority - they enhance local search visibility and make your business more prominent when customers look you up. As Google explains:

High-quality, positive reviews from your customers can improve your business visibility and increase the likelihood that a shopper will visit your location.

If you're in the U.S., Yelp is another powerhouse for local businesses, drawing over 120 million visits monthly. It's especially effective for restaurants, retail shops, and service-based businesses where local discovery is key. Facebook also plays a role by encouraging social engagement. Reviews on Facebook often act as word-of-mouth recommendations, visible to customers' friends.

For specialized businesses, industry-specific platforms are invaluable. For example:

• TripAdvisor: Perfect for hotels, restaurants, and tourism businesses, with 78.8 million U.S. travelers visiting monthly.
• Angi: Ideal for home service providers like contractors, plumbers, and landscapers.
• Trustpilot: A go-to for e-commerce and global brands looking to establish credibility on an international level.
• Better Business Bureau (BBB): Trusted by over 140 million users annually, it’s a strong choice for BBB-accredited businesses.
• Foursquare: Offers audience insights that can inform your marketing strategies.

When deciding, think about where your target audience spends their time, how much effort it takes to maintain a presence, and the unique features each platform offers. For instance, a local bakery might focus on Google and Yelp for visibility, while an online retailer could lean on Google and Trustpilot for building credibility. Interestingly, 48% of U.S. adults also rely on local news outlets for business reviews.

These platform choices lay the groundwork for streamlined review management, which kisReviews makes even easier.

How kisReviews Simplifies Review Management

kisReviews takes the hassle out of managing reviews by automating the process. It uses QR codes that customers can scan to leave reviews instantly, removing barriers to feedback.

The platform’s centralized dashboard gathers reviews from sources like Google, Yelp, and Facebook, so you can respond promptly. Its analytics tools help you track trends, gauge customer sentiment, and fine-tune your strategy. Plus, you can customize review requests and displays to match your brand’s style.

As your business grows, kisReviews scales with you, handling more reviews without extra manual effort. Its integration capabilities connect smoothly with your existing systems, making review collection feel like a natural part of your customer interactions. This not only saves time but also strengthens customer trust.

kisReviews offers three pricing tiers:

• Free Plan: Includes one location, 10 text reviews, and two platforms - great for testing.
• Essential Plan: Costs $20 annually ($25 monthly) and supports two locations with unlimited reviews and platforms.
• Growth Plan: Priced at $50 annually ($60 monthly), it covers up to 10 locations and offers unlimited dynamic QR codes.

The interface is simple to use, requiring minimal training for your team. And if technical issues arise, their responsive support team is there to help.

Staying Compliant with Privacy and Data Security

While managing reviews, keeping customer data secure is non-negotiable. U.S. privacy laws require businesses to navigate a patchwork of federal, state, and local regulations. Unlike Europe’s GDPR, the U.S. lacks a single national privacy law. Key state laws include the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA), Texas Data Privacy and Security Act, and Virginia Consumer Data Protection Act, among others.

To stay compliant, always obtain clear and informed consent before collecting customer data. Explain what information you’re collecting, how it will be used, and provide an easy opt-out option. Use strong encryption standards like TLS and AES 256 to protect sensitive data.

Limit data collection to what’s necessary - typically an email or phone number for follow-up requests. Regular privacy audits can ensure your practices remain effective and compliant. With over 3,200 data breaches reported last year in the U.S. and only 56% of companies prepared with response plans, proactive measures are essential.

Train your team on data privacy rules, strengthen agreements with third-party vendors, and stay informed about regulatory updates. Whether you assign an internal team member or hire a compliance consultant, these efforts not only meet legal requirements but also build trust with your customers.

As Kate Ruane from the American Civil Liberties Union puts it:

We have these companies that are amassing just gigantic amounts of data about each and every one of us, all day, every day.

Transparent and secure data practices aren’t just about following the law - they’re key to earning and keeping your customers’ trust.

Setting Up Review Collection Systems

Establishing an automated system to gather customer feedback is crucial. By integrating this system with your platforms, you can ensure a steady flow of reviews while keeping the process efficient and hassle-free.

Creating a System for Review Requests

Timing is everything when it comes to asking for reviews. Reach out while the customer's experience is still fresh. For physical products, send review requests 3–5 days after delivery. For services, aim for 24–48 hours after completion. Automating these workflows ensures requests are sent at the right moment without manual intervention.

Use email and SMS to make it easy for customers to share their thoughts. For example, 91% of consumers check their email daily, with 58% making it their first online activity of the day. Including direct links to review platforms in your messages can simplify the process even further.

QR codes are another great tool for bridging offline and online interactions. You can include them on receipts, packaging, or business cards, allowing customers to scan and leave a review instantly. Platforms like kisReviews make this even easier by eliminating the need for customers to search for your business online or type in URLs.

Before requesting reviews, ensure that the customer’s experience is complete - whether that means their issue has been resolved, their product has arrived, or their service has been fulfilled. Avoid jumping the gun by asking for a review at the first positive comment. Instead, create opportunities for genuine, thoughtful feedback.

By automating these steps, you can create a seamless process for collecting reviews while keeping the experience personal and effective.

Writing Better Review Requests

When asking for reviews, personalization matters. Address customers by name, keep your message short, and include a clear call to action. A straightforward, friendly tone can make all the difference in encouraging responses.

Incentives can also encourage participation, but timing is key. Offering rewards with a 30–60 day window motivates customers to act quickly while keeping the process fair.

Make sure your review links are mobile-friendly, as many customers will likely respond via their phones. The stats back this up: 76% of people asked to leave reviews eventually do so.

Finally, express gratitude in your messages. A simple "thank you" goes a long way in showing appreciation and building a positive connection.

Providing Multiple Ways to Leave Reviews

Convenience is critical when collecting reviews. By offering multiple channels, you make it easier for customers to share their feedback. Consider options like email, in-app prompts, website widgets, SMS, and social media. A diversified approach helps you gather insights from a broader audience.

For digital channels, include direct links in emails that lead to platforms like your Google Business Profile or Yelp page. Add review buttons to thank-you pages, email signatures, and even order confirmation or shipping notification pages for e-commerce sites.

Offline methods are just as effective. QR codes on receipts, packaging, or business cards connect in-person experiences with your online review system. Customers can scan and leave feedback without extra effort.

Social media can also expand your reach. For example, you can use email surveys with links to review sites or directly connect your review profiles to your website and social channels. A great example comes from 2024, when The Dogist Shop used Instagram Stories to gather feedback on their holiday product lines and followed up with polls to gauge customer interest.

To maximize results, ensure your feedback options are accessible at multiple touchpoints - right after purchase, upon delivery, or during follow-up communications. The easier it is for customers to share their experiences, the more likely they are to do so.

Responding to and Managing Reviews

Once your review collection systems are up and running, the next challenge is managing and responding to those reviews effectively. How you reply to feedback - whether glowing praise or harsh criticism - shapes how people see your business. Here's a striking fact: 89% of consumers read responses to negative reviews, and 97% of people reading reviews also pay attention to company replies. Every response you write contributes to your brand's public identity.

Responding to Reviews Quickly

Timeliness is everything. 53% of customers expect businesses to respond to negative reviews within a week, but waiting that long could already harm your reputation. Aim to respond within 24–72 hours to show you care and to safeguard your image. Customer service expert Chip Bell puts it perfectly:

In the customer's mind, the clock starts when he or she posts a negative review, and your reputation drops with every hour you delay providing a response. Bad reviews that remain unanswered signal to other customers you are disinterested. It also fuels the perception that the negative report by an angry customer was probably accurate.

Make your responses personal. Address the reviewer by name and thank them for their feedback, even if it's critical. For positive reviews, highlight the specific details they loved. When dealing with negative reviews, express empathy and apologize - even if the issue wasn’t entirely your fault.

Take ownership of the problem and provide a clear solution. Share direct contact details to move the conversation offline, and invite the customer to give your business another chance. A personalized, timely response can work wonders: 79% of customers say they are "likely" or "highly likely" to leave a positive review after a business addresses their concerns and resolves the issue.

And here's another reason to prioritize responsiveness: it can directly impact sales. Consumers are 116% more likely to make a purchase after seeing a business respond to a negative review. Plus, 64% of customers prefer to buy from companies that take the time to reply.

But responding quickly is just the beginning - digging into the data behind reviews can take your strategy to the next level.

Tracking Review Trends with Analytics

Beyond writing replies, analyzing review trends can unlock valuable insights about your customers. Businesses that respond to more than 25% of their reviews report earning 35% more revenue on average. But the real gold lies in understanding the recurring themes behind customer feedback.

Modern tools like kisReviews use AI to categorize reviews, identify common complaints, and analyze sentiment. These tools are becoming the norm - by 2024, AI is expected to manage over 75% of customer interactions across various industries.

Look for patterns in the feedback. Are customers mentioning the same issue repeatedly? Are specific products or services being praised or criticized? Spotting these trends allows you to address problems proactively instead of waiting for them to escalate. Companies that integrate AI into their customer experience strategies often see a 20% increase in customer satisfaction while cutting operational costs by 10%.

Track key metrics like response rates, sentiment trends, and resolution times. Pay attention to which types of responses generate the most positive follow-ups. This data can help refine your approach and guide your team on how to respond effectively.

Finally, share these insights across your organization. Customer support teams need to know about service complaints, product development teams should hear recurring feature requests, and marketing teams can leverage positive themes in their messaging. Even sales teams can benefit from understanding common objections or praise points.

Sharing Updates Based on Customer Feedback

Transparency is a powerful way to build trust, especially when you act on customer suggestions. Over 50% of people change their opinion of a business when it responds to their concerns. Taking it a step further - by publicly sharing the improvements you’ve made based on feedback - can foster even deeper loyalty.

Let customers know their voices matter. Share updates about changes inspired by their feedback on your website, email newsletters, or social media. And don’t forget to respond to the original reviewers to let them know their input led to real action.

Take Webroot, for example. The internet security company responded to 70% of its low-rated reviews, improving the shopping experience and adding a human touch to its brand. Drew Frey, their Community and Advocacy Manager, explains:

We value hearing from customers and need this constant feedback loop, whether it's negative or positive, or we aren't going to get better.

Create a system to document the changes you make and follow up with customers who provided the original suggestions. This demonstrates that you’re not just listening - you’re acting. Businesses that respond to complaints on review sites see a 16% boost in customer advocacy.

You could even create a "You Asked, We Listened" section on your website or include it in marketing materials. Highlight specific suggestions from customers and showcase the changes you’ve made. This level of transparency shows that customer feedback directly shapes your business decisions, which can significantly strengthen loyalty and trust.

Solving Common Review Collection Problems

Even the most well-designed systems can hit snags when it comes to gathering customer reviews. Understanding these challenges and how to tackle them can make a big difference. Addressing these obstacles complements earlier strategies and ensures that no feedback opportunity is missed.

Fixing Low Response Rates

Low response rates are a frequent issue, often tied to how surveys are designed or how engaging they are. Research shows that sending follow-ups can significantly increase response rates - from 20–30% to over 85%.

Clare Zacharias, a Content Marketer at SurveySparrow, emphasizes simplicity:

Don't use too many words when a few will do! Make your survey questions short and simple.

The numbers support this: surveys that take 5 minutes or less to complete perform the best. For instance, a 10-question survey boasts an 89% completion rate, whereas a 40-question survey sees that drop to 79% or less.

Timing also matters. Emails sent around 1:00 PM achieve a 22% click-to-open rate. Adding a personal touch - like including the customer's name and purchase details - along with one to three gentle reminders can boost response rates by up to 48% .

Offering small incentives can also work wonders. Instead of dangling a big reward for a few, try giving a modest thank-you to every participant.

While boosting response rates is important, handling negative feedback requires a different, more proactive approach.

Dealing with Negative Reviews

Negative reviews can feel like a setback, but they’re actually an opportunity to build trust and improve your service. Interestingly, 30% of consumers suspect reviews are fake if there are no negative ones, and 52% trust a product more when they see a mix of positive and negative feedback.

Responding quickly is crucial - 87% of consumers expect a reply. Addressing negative reviews within 24–48 hours can turn them into trust-building moments. When handled well, 79% of customers are more likely to leave a positive review, and 76% may even update a negative review to a neutral or positive one .

Joe Burton, CEO of Reputation, explains the value of responding to criticism:

A negative review where there's some sense the company made good or the company made a correction almost becomes a superpowered review. The authenticity of it - they love that this is a normal company with normal humans.

Negative feedback is also a goldmine for learning. Charles Damore, Customer Communications Supervisor at Marleyspoon, shares:

We proactively ask our customers to leave feedback, then categorize our negative responses into issue codes. We then report these to the relevant departments and work together to identify root causes and bottlenecks in our process and work on improving them immediately.

For more complex issues, taking the conversation offline shows your commitment to resolving the problem. This approach aligns with an overall review management strategy and can shift customer perceptions - 71% of consumers say their opinion of a brand has improved after reading a thoughtful response to a review.

Keeping Up with Changing Customer Expectations

Beyond addressing immediate challenges, staying in tune with evolving customer expectations is critical for long-term success in review collection.

Customer expectations don’t stay static. For example, 80% of consumers are more likely to buy from brands that offer personalized experiences. Treat feedback as an ongoing dialogue with your customers.

Show customers you’re listening by making real, visible improvements. When changes are made based on feedback, it encourages more participation in the future. As Bill Gates famously said:

Your most unhappy customers are your greatest source of learning.

Leverage AI and automation to streamline processes, but don’t lose the human touch in customer interactions. Transparency is also key - be upfront about how you collect, store, and use customer data, and give customers control over their information.

Finally, consistency is everything. Ensure a seamless experience across all platforms - whether it’s in-store, online, via email, or on social media. A unified approach to review collection builds trust and strengthens customer relationships over time.

Conclusion: Building Trust Through Better Review Collection

Creating a reliable system for collecting reviews isn't just a nice-to-have - it’s a game changer for building trust and driving growth. Online reviews play a massive role in consumer behavior, with 95% of shoppers reading them before making a purchase and 58% willing to spend more after seeing positive feedback. The strategies we've covered in this checklist build step-by-step toward helping new businesses tap into this powerful opportunity.

These methods are effective because they focus on what truly matters to customers: authenticity and responsiveness. For instance, when 70% of consumers say they trust reviews more when they come from verified customers, it becomes clear how vital it is to prioritize genuine feedback. As Jacquelyn Van Sant, owner of Waymarks, explains:

"Positive reviews do more for building trust with potential clients than anything you say yourself." - Jacquelyn Van Sant

Consistency is the backbone of trust. Whether it's setting clear goals or reaching out to customers personally, every step in this process reinforces a stable and trustworthy relationship. And don’t overlook the importance of engagement - 88% of shoppers are more likely to choose businesses that actively respond to all reviews. It’s not just about collecting feedback; it’s about showing customers you value their input.

Automation can help maintain this consistency without overloading your team. With 98% of consumers checking reviews before making decisions, ensuring a steady flow of feedback can set your business apart in a crowded market.

The numbers speak volumes about the benefits of a structured approach. Products with five or more reviews are 270% more likely to be purchased, and review signals account for around 15% of local SEO ranking factors. For businesses looking to establish credibility quickly, this combination of social proof and improved search visibility creates a powerful foundation for growth.

FAQs

What are the best ways to ask customers for reviews without sounding pushy?

The secret to asking for reviews without coming across as pushy lies in being thoughtful and intentional. Timing is everything - reach out shortly after a positive interaction, like when a customer completes a purchase or receives a service. This is when their experience is still fresh, and they’re most likely to share their thoughts.

Keep your request personal and sincere. Use their name and mention the specific product or service they used. A tailored message feels far more genuine than a cookie-cutter approach.

Make the process as simple as possible by offering clear instructions on how to leave a review. Include multiple platform options, like Google or Yelp, so they can pick what’s convenient for them. And don’t forget to show appreciation. Thank them for their time and explain how their feedback helps your business grow. This creates a sense of collaboration and makes the request feel natural, not forced.

How can I respond to negative reviews in a way that improves my business's reputation?

Responding to negative reviews in the right way can actually help build trust with your audience. The first step? Acknowledge the customer's concerns sincerely and without delay. A personalized response shows you’re listening and that their feedback matters. On the flip side, generic replies can feel robotic and dismissive - definitely not the impression you want to leave.

In some cases, it’s best to move the conversation offline. Suggest continuing the discussion via email or phone so you can address the issue in more detail. This approach not only shows your commitment to resolving the problem but also keeps sensitive details private. After resolving the matter, you can politely ask the customer if they’d consider updating their review to reflect the resolution. This not only helps repair your reputation but also reassures future customers that you genuinely care about delivering great service.

How can I make sure my review collection supports my business goals and drives growth?

To make sure your approach to collecting reviews aligns with your business goals and supports growth, start by defining specific objectives that match your key priorities. For instance, you might aim to enhance customer satisfaction, improve retention rates, or drive sales. By connecting your review strategy to these goals, you can use customer feedback in a purposeful way to fine-tune your products, services, and overall customer experience.

Keep an eye on key performance indicators (KPIs) to gauge the impact of reviews on your business. Metrics like customer acquisition, retention rates, and revenue growth can reveal how reviews contribute to your success. With these insights, you’ll be better equipped to make informed decisions that improve your marketing strategies and deepen customer connections. A thoughtful review strategy doesn’t just build trust - it delivers measurable results that can elevate your business.

Related posts

• Top 10 Review Management Software for Businesses
• Top 7 Ways to Display Customer Reviews on Website