Google Reviews vs Yelp Reviews: Which Matters More?

Which review platform should you focus on? It depends on your business goals. Here’s a quick breakdown:

• Google Reviews: Best for broad reach, local SEO, and quick decisions. With 57.5% of all online reviews globally and integration with Google Maps, it’s ideal for improving visibility and attracting a wide audience.
• Yelp Reviews: Best for detailed feedback and trust-building. Yelp’s affluent, engaged audience values in-depth reviews, making it a strong choice for industries like restaurants and services.

Key Facts:

• 83% of people use Google to check local business reviews.
• A one-star increase on Yelp can boost revenue by 5–9%.
• 77% of consumers trust online reviews as "mostly" trustworthy.

Quick Comparison:

Feature	Google Reviews	Yelp Reviews
Audience Reach	Over 1 billion users globally	133.68 million monthly visits
Review Style	Short, concise	Detailed, photo-rich
SEO Impact	Strong local SEO benefits	Local discovery focus
User Demographics	Broad, diverse	Affluent, educated, older audience
Management Control	Flexible, easy to manage	Stricter rules, less control

Takeaway: Use both platforms strategically. Google boosts visibility, while Yelp builds trust through detailed reviews. Together, they strengthen your online reputation and drive revenue.

Are Google Reviews Better than Yelp Reviews?

Google Reviews: Reach and Local Business Impact

With Google commanding a massive 91.5% share of the global search market and hosting 57.5% of all online reviews, it’s no surprise that Google Reviews play a pivotal role in increasing business visibility and driving revenue .

How Google Reviews Connect with Search and Maps

Google Reviews are seamlessly woven into the fabric of the world’s most popular search engine and mapping service. When users perform local searches, reviews appear alongside business listings, giving businesses a boost in visibility. This is particularly important since 46% of Google searches are tied to local intent, meaning nearly half of all queries are from users looking for nearby services or businesses.

Google prioritizes businesses with complete and accurate profiles, rewarding them with better search rankings. Adding photos to a Google Maps listing can increase requests for driving directions by an impressive 42%. Additionally, businesses with well-rounded profiles are 2.7 times more likely to be perceived as trustworthy.

Google's User Base and Market Share

The sheer scale of Google’s reach is staggering. Every minute, the platform handles approximately 5.9 million searches, delivering around 492 billion search results monthly.

For consumers, Google has become the go-to platform for evaluating local businesses. A significant 83% of people check Google reviews before making decisions about local services. Moreover, 88% of customers read these reviews to gauge a business’s quality and reputation, while 74% say positive reviews build trust. Having a Google Business Profile further influences customer behavior, with 58% of users saying it increases the likelihood they’ll visit a physical location. In fact, 63.6% of consumers check reviews on Google before stepping into a business. Businesses with 200 or more reviews can experience a revenue boost of over 100% compared to those with fewer reviews - specifically, just 82 reviews.

Next, we’ll dive into how business owners can effectively manage these reviews to maximize their local impact.

Managing Google Reviews for Business Owners

Given Google’s extensive reach, managing reviews effectively is crucial for businesses. Top-performing businesses tend to have an average of 47 reviews and maintain ratings of 4.0 stars or higher, which helps them rank for terms like "best" or "top" in search results.

The recency of reviews also matters - a whopping 73% of users trust only reviews posted within the last 30 days. Keeping your review profile updated not only builds credibility but also encourages consistent customer engagement. Responding to reviews, whether positive or negative, shows dedication to customer satisfaction and signals active management of feedback.

Streamlining the review process can make a big difference. Businesses can send direct review links through text or email to encourage customer feedback. Asking for detailed reviews, including photos, can further improve local search rankings. On the flip side, addressing negative reviews quickly is critical, as unresolved complaints can drive away up to 70% of potential customers.

Lastly, Google reviews can boost website conversion rates by as much as 15%. When customers mention specific services or locations in their reviews, it helps Google associate the business with relevant local searches, amplifying visibility.

These strategies underscore the importance of a well-executed Google review plan to build trust and drive local business growth.

Yelp Reviews: Community Focus and User Engagement

While Google may dominate the review world, Yelp has carved out its own space by prioritizing quality over quantity. With a whopping 287 million reviews as of December 31, 2023, and 178 million unique monthly visitors, Yelp attracts users who are serious about sharing thoughtful experiences and making well-informed choices. Let’s take a closer look at how Yelp’s filtering system ensures its reviews stand out.

Yelp's Review Quality and Filtering System

Yelp’s focus on reliable reviews is what sets it apart. The platform uses advanced filtering algorithms to weed out biased or unreliable content, ensuring users see reviews they can trust. This approach has paid off, with 83% of people trusting Yelp reviews for local businesses.

In 2021 alone, Yelp removed over 218,600 reviews that violated its policies, further solidifying its reputation for high standards. Interestingly, 85% of users trust reviews with written explanations more than just star ratings, showing the value of detailed feedback.

This level of trust translates into action: 90% of Yelp users compare businesses before deciding where to spend their money. On average, users read five reviews about a business before making a decision, and 77% report reading more online reviews now than ever before.

One standout example of Yelp’s impact is Cocina Madrigal in Phoenix, Arizona. In 2022, this restaurant climbed to the top of Yelp’s Top 100 Places to Eat list thanks to its outstanding service and exceptional food. Hundreds of five-star reviews propelled it into the spotlight, even earning a feature on The Kelly Clarkson Show.

"We owe everything to those guests who have been coming to us from day one. It all began with our early customers, who were the first ones to give us a chance and take the time to give us feedback, whether it was on Yelp or in person, for us to be able to improve and grow." - Brian Madrigal, co-owner of Cocina Madrigal

This example highlights how Yelp’s commitment to quality fosters trust and drives success for businesses.

Who Uses Yelp and Why

Yelp attracts high-intent, affluent shoppers actively searching for local businesses. In the U.S., 56% of Yelp users earn $100,000 or more annually, and 62% have attended college. The platform also appeals to older audiences, with 39% of users aged 55 and older.

This affluent user base aligns with strong buying behavior. A staggering 97% of Yelp users make purchases from businesses they find on the platform, and 93% compare options before committing. Even more compelling, 92% of Yelp users who research businesses end up making a purchase or booking a service.

Mobile usage plays a huge role in Yelp’s success, with 92 million monthly mobile users accessing the platform. This mobile-first focus fits perfectly with the way people search for local businesses on-the-go, especially when looking for immediate solutions.

Interestingly, women write 61% of Yelp reviews, showcasing their active involvement. Yelp users with active profiles are also highly engaged, writing ten times more reviews than anonymous users, which speaks to the platform’s sense of community.

What Makes Yelp Reviews Different

Yelp’s users aren’t just leaving star ratings - they’re sharing detailed, photo-rich reviews that paint a full picture of their experiences. With over 37 million photos uploaded to the platform, these visuals add an extra layer of authenticity to reviews. This trend of including photos and even videos helps build trust and provides more context for potential customers.

"Customers come to Yelp for more than just star ratings and reviews...They want to see photos, services offered, price quotes, and much more." - Saisuman Revankar, Writer, Coolest Gadgets

Yelp reviews also tend to be more in-depth than those on other platforms. While 52% of all Yelp reviews are five-star, they often include detailed explanations that help readers make informed decisions. In fact, 45% of people check Yelp reviews before visiting a business, underscoring the platform’s influence.

Beyond individual reviews, Yelp fosters a sense of community. Users exchange recommendations and discuss local businesses, creating an interactive environment where 79% of people view online reviews as crucial when deciding where to go.

Yelp’s reach is impressive, operating in 35 countries and offering content in 42 languages. Popular categories reflect local needs, with Home & Local Services accounting for 20% of reviews and restaurants making up 17%.

The platform also integrates with social media, allowing users to share their reviews beyond Yelp itself. This not only amplifies the impact of individual reviews but also strengthens the community-driven vibe that makes Yelp a standout in the review space.

Google Reviews vs Yelp Reviews: Side-by-Side Analysis

Now that we’ve broken down the strengths of each platform individually, it’s time to compare them directly. Below, we’ll dive into the key differences between Google Reviews and Yelp Reviews to help you decide which platform aligns best with your business goals and customer engagement needs.

5 Key Areas to Compare

Audience Reach and Scale

Google’s reach is massive, with over 1 billion users worldwide and 83% of people using it to find local businesses. In comparison, Yelp operates on a smaller scale, attracting about 133.68 million global monthly visits, with 87.1% of that traffic coming from the United States. When it comes to sheer volume, Google dominates, accounting for 57.5% of all online reviews globally.

Review Quality and Detail

Google Reviews are often concise, featuring a star rating and a brief comment. On the other hand, Yelp reviews are known for their depth. They frequently include detailed narratives, star ratings, and even photos. While 81% of consumers turn to Google for quick reviews, 45.18% prefer Yelp when they want more in-depth insights.

User Demographics and Engagement

The audiences for these platforms differ significantly. Google attracts a broad and diverse global user base, while Yelp resonates more with an affluent, educated, and slightly older demographic. Yelp also fosters stronger user engagement through features like profiles, social connections, and badges, whereas Google’s interaction is limited to reviews and ratings.

Business Visibility and SEO Impact

Google Reviews directly influence local search rankings and integrate seamlessly with Google Maps, making businesses with positive reviews four times more likely to attract customers. Yelp, on the other hand, emphasizes local discovery. Studies show that a one-star increase on Yelp can lead to a 5–9% boost in revenue.

Management and Control

Google provides businesses with more flexibility through its Google Business Profile, which allows for easy updates and review management. Collecting reviews on Google is also simpler. While both platforms enable businesses to respond to reviews, Yelp has stricter rules against soliciting reviews and offers less control over business profiles.

Platform Comparison Chart

Feature	Google Reviews	Yelp Reviews
Audience Reach	Over 1 billion users globally; 83% use it for local searches	133.68 million monthly visits; 87.1% from the U.S.
Review Quality	Short reviews with brief comments	Detailed reviews with photos and extensive feedback
User Demographics	Broad, diverse global audience	Affluent, educated, older demographics
Business Visibility	Integrated with search results and Google Maps	Focused on local discovery
SEO Impact	Strong local SEO benefits; 4× more likely to attract customers	One-star increase can boost revenue by 5–9%
Review Volume	57.5% of all online reviews globally	Smaller volume but higher engagement
Management Control	Full control over Google Business Profile; easier to collect reviews	Limited control; strict solicitation rules
Social Features	Minimal social interaction beyond reviews	Robust community features (profiles, badges)
Best For	Quick discovery, SEO boosts, and broad reach	Detailed feedback and strong local reputation

This comparison reveals two distinct approaches to online reviews. Google excels in reach and visibility, making it ideal for quick decisions and SEO benefits. In contrast, Yelp prioritizes detailed, thoughtful feedback, which can help build trust and a strong local presence. Depending on your business’s needs, one may offer a better fit than the other - or you might find value in leveraging both.

How to Get the Most from Both Review Platforms

Building on the differences between Google and Yelp reviews, actively managing both platforms can strengthen trust and boost revenue. Here's how to make the most of your review management efforts.

How to Respond to Reviews the Right Way

The Power of Response

Responding to reviews isn’t just polite - it’s powerful. Research shows that 89% of consumers are more likely to choose a business that responds to all reviews, and 70% are more inclined to leave a review when businesses engage with them.

Dennis Akers, owner of The Candle Pour, explains his philosophy:

"If there is a negative review, it's a good teaching moment. No matter what it is, even if we didn't do anything wrong, it's still a good teaching moment. So we do address that. We try to respond to every single review to say, 'Thank you.'"

Responding to Positive Reviews

Positive reviews deserve attention too. Vadim Nayman of Bagel Master emphasizes the importance of acknowledging all feedback:

"On every platform, I comment back on every review - good, bad, or ugly - because I think it's very important. Why would you only respond to the negative? You have to reach out to the people that took their time to give you a positive review and let them know that you appreciate them."

A simple, heartfelt thank-you can go a long way in strengthening customer relationships.

Handling Negative Reviews

Negative reviews call for a measured and thoughtful response. Nic Faitos of Starbright Floral Design advises:

"If you have something good to say, say it right away. If you don't, take a deep breath."

Instead of rushing to reply, take time to understand the issue. Then, respond professionally and sincerely. Faitos explains:

"I'm not concerned about getting the person to change the hypothetical 1-star review to a 2-star review or a 5-star review. I'm not looking for more stars. I want to talk about that for a moment. I'm looking to express sincerity. I'm looking to express care and I'm looking to express, 'What can we do to make this right?'"

These examples highlight the importance of a consistent, thoughtful approach when replying to reviews.

Response Best Practices

When crafting your replies:

• Thank the reviewer and address their key points.
• Maintain a professional, genuine tone.
• Offer to continue the conversation offline if needed.

Data shows that 97% of consumers reading reviews also check the business’s responses, and 53% expect a reply within a week. Additionally, 86% are more likely to overlook a negative review if they see the business has addressed the issue.

Using the right tools can make managing responses much easier.

Tools That Make Review Management Easier

As your business grows, managing reviews efficiently becomes critical. Here’s how technology can help:

• Automated Review Collection: Tools like kisReviews simplify the process by sending automated review requests and generating QR codes. This makes it easy for happy customers to leave feedback on Google and Yelp.
• Centralized Review Management: Instead of juggling multiple accounts, a centralized dashboard lets you monitor and respond to reviews from both platforms in one place, saving time and ensuring consistency.
• Review Display and SEO Benefits: Customizable widgets allow you to showcase reviews directly on your website, boosting social proof and improving search engine rankings.
• Analytics and Performance Tracking: By analyzing trends, response rates, and the impact on your reputation, you can make informed decisions and allocate resources effectively.

These tools streamline the process, making it easier to stay on top of your review strategy.

Matching Your Review Strategy to Business Goals

Aligning your review management efforts with your business objectives is key. Here’s how to tailor your strategy:

For Maximum Visibility and SEO Impact
If your goal is to improve local search visibility, focus on Google Reviews. Google accounts for 73% of all business reviews, and 70% of consumers are more likely to click on businesses with positive Google reviews. Ensure your Google Business Profile is complete and encourage reviews with QR codes or direct links.

For Building Reputation and Trust
For businesses like restaurants or professional services, where detailed feedback matters, prioritize Yelp. About 94% of users rely on Yelp reviews when making purchasing decisions. Enhance your Yelp presence with check-in offers, regular updates, and in-store reminders of your profile.

For Revenue Growth
Both platforms can drive revenue when managed well. Studies show that every additional one-star review can increase revenue by 5-9%. On Google, aim for a high volume of reviews to boost rankings. On Yelp, focus on quality engagement to showcase your dedication to customer care.

Balancing Both Platforms
A dual-platform approach often yields the best results. Use Google for broad visibility and customer acquisition, while leveraging Yelp to build a detailed reputation and foster community engagement. Keith Zeiler, owner of Paws on Chicon, shares:

"It's all about how people are going to treat your business and see your business. If you're just letting things sit there with no response, [as a customer,] I'm more likely to go to a business that acknowledges me and says, 'Thank you for taking the time to write a review.' Because no one has to do it, and for them to do that means a lot."

Engaging with reviews consistently can lead to real results. Businesses that actively manage responses see a 12% increase in review volume on average, and about 33% improve their overall rating by half a star or more within six months.

Which Review Platform Should You Focus On?

To build a strong online reputation, it's smart to tap into the strengths of both Google and Yelp. Each platform offers unique benefits that can work together to enhance your visibility and credibility.

Google Reviews are the cornerstone of your online presence. With over 83% of reviews happening on Google, it’s the go-to platform for local searches. It’s not just about quantity - Google reviews are trusted by 88% of customers as much as personal recommendations. Plus, 83% of people check Google reviews before making a purchase decision. For businesses aiming to boost local SEO and attract a broad audience, Google Reviews are a must.

On the other hand, Yelp excels at fostering detailed engagement. Boasting 133.68 million monthly visits, Yelp’s community-driven format encourages in-depth feedback. This is especially important for industries like restaurants, where detailed reviews can influence customer choices. Even more compelling? 57% of Yelp users contact a business within a day of visiting the platform. And don’t overlook the financial impact: improving your Yelp rating by just one star can increase revenue by 5–9%.

The best approach? Use both platforms to your advantage. Google’s massive reach and quick decision-making power pair perfectly with Yelp’s detailed, trust-building reviews. Together, they can drive traffic, boost conversions, and build confidence among both consumers and B2B buyers.

To simplify managing reviews across platforms, tools like kisReviews can be a game-changer. These tools automate review collection, centralize responses, and even help you showcase the best reviews on your website. This way, you can harness the unique strengths of each platform while maintaining a consistent and polished online reputation.

The takeaway? Businesses that succeed know how to navigate both platforms effectively.

FAQs

How can businesses effectively use both Google and Yelp reviews to build a strong online reputation?

To get the most out of Google and Yelp reviews, businesses should prioritize managing their presence on both platforms. Start by keeping an eye on reviews and responding to them regularly. This approach shows customers that their opinions matter, helps build trust, and enhances your brand's reputation.

Encourage satisfied customers to share their experiences on both platforms. Google reviews can help improve your local search rankings, making it easier for new customers to discover your business. Meanwhile, Yelp is often a go-to for recommendations, especially for restaurants and service-based businesses. By balancing your efforts across these platforms, you’ll boost visibility, reach a broader audience, and strengthen customer loyalty.

How can businesses encourage detailed and positive Yelp reviews effectively?

To inspire detailed and positive Yelp reviews, start by focusing on delivering exceptional customer service and offering top-notch products or services. When customers leave your business feeling satisfied and valued, they’re much more likely to share their good experiences online.

Make sure your Yelp profile stands out by keeping it complete and visually engaging. Update your business details regularly, upload high-quality photos, and respond to reviews - whether they’re glowing or critical. This not only shows you care about customer feedback but also encourages others to interact with your page.

You can also gently encourage reviews by including reminders in follow-up emails, on receipts, or during casual conversations. Just be mindful of Yelp’s rules, which discourage directly asking for reviews. Finally, take the time to review your existing feedback. Spotting patterns or common suggestions can help you refine your services, creating even better experiences that naturally lead to positive reviews.

How do differences in user demographics and engagement on Google and Yelp affect a business's review strategy?

The way user demographics and engagement vary between Google and Yelp can significantly influence how you approach review management.

Google Reviews caters to a broad audience. Most people use it to quickly search for and evaluate local businesses, making it an excellent tool for increasing visibility and drawing in a diverse customer base.

Meanwhile, Yelp appeals to a more community-oriented audience. Yelp users often provide detailed, thoughtful reviews, making it a valuable platform for businesses aiming to establish trust and build deeper relationships with customers.

For the best results, businesses can leverage Google to gain wide exposure and facilitate quick decisions, while turning to Yelp to connect with engaged users who appreciate detailed feedback.

Related posts

• Review Collection Checklist for New Businesses
• Why Customers Don't Leave Reviews: Common Problems
• QR Code Review Collection: Complete Setup Guide